Sarah was one of several students in a group led by Jason and consisting of Oscar, Lara Croft, Amanda Evert, Anaya Imanu, Eva, Kent and an unnamed male. Unfortunately, their expedition into the tomb of the last Queen of Tiwanaku woke up an entity of unknown origin placed there to protect it. It killed Eva, then chased Sarah into another room and killed her. Sarah's body was later found by Lara, causing her to wonder what happened. Sarah has no lines and is only seen lying dead in the first room of the flashback level in Tomb Raider: Legend. Her corpse bears a strong resemblance to a younger Amanda Evert.